USDEC 18, 2025
We Asked AI Platforms To Grade Trump’s TV Address. Their Conclusions Were Remarkably Consistent
Advertisement
In an address from the White House that lasted less than 20 minutes, President Donald Trump described an America transformed, a country he said had been pulled back “from the brink of ruin” under his leadership.
The address spoke of a resurrected nation where inflation had vanished, migrants were gone, wages were soaring, employment was rising, and wars were settled.
Highlights
- Four major AI platforms fact-checked Trump's speech and unanimously found most claims to be exaggerated or false, assigning grades from F to C-.
- Inflation claims were rated mostly false; inflation peaked before Trump took office and has not stopped despite his assertion.
- Trump's immigration claims, including an 'army of 25 million' and 'zero illegal aliens allowed,' were rated false and massively exaggerated.
- Statements about drug price cuts over 100% and opening 1,600 power plants in a year were flagged as mathematically impossible or implausible.
America is now “the hottest country anywhere in the world,” Trump claimed, citing “every single leader” that he has “spoken to over the last five months.”
BP Daily asked four AI chatbots to fact-check Trump’s speech and give him a grade from ‘A+ to F’
Image credits: The White House/X
So BP Daily conducted an experiment. We gave the full transcript of Trump’s speech to four major AI platforms and asked them to grade its factual accuracy. And, as expected, they all failed him.
“Fact-check all the claims made by Donald Trump in his 17 Dec speech and assign him a grade from A+ to F based on their correctness,” was the prompt input into chatbot models ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Grok.
The chatbots assigned a score while checking his claims on major categories, including the economy, border and immigration, the election, health care, the military, and foreign policy.
Two platforms, ChatGPT and Claude, gave the speech an outright F. Gemini graded it a C-, citing a mix of real policy actions with exaggerated claims and “alternative math.”
Grok issued a D, concluding that roughly 60% of the speech’s claims were exaggerated or false.
Image credits: Grok
Despite differences in scoring, all four reached the same conclusion: that the speech consistently overstated achievements and relied on unsupported numbers.
Most of his claims were categorized as “exaggerated” or outright “false.”
“When I took office, inflation was the worst in 48 years, and some would say in the history of our country,” was one of the first claims Trump made.
Verdict: “False/Misleading/Exaggerated,” the models said, highlighting the fact that inflation actually peaked at 9.1% in June 2022 and had already fallen significantly before Trump took office.
Image credits: CNBC
His continued claim was that inflation has “stopped” and prices are down, which was categorized as being “mostly false.”
While inflation has slowed down, it has not stopped. CNN fact checked that the year-over-year inflation rate of 3% in September was the same as the rate when Trump returned to office in January.
Claims that gasoline is now widely $1.99 a gallon, groceries are “coming down fast,” Thanksgiving turkeys are down 33%, and eggs are down 82% were also rejected.
Trump failed, with two out of four chatbots giving him an ‘F’
Image credits: ChatGPT
While egg and turkey prices have fallen from temporary spikes, none of the online-enabled chatbots found evidence supporting the scale Trump cited.
Trump said that 100% of jobs created since he took office were in the private sector, and that wages are now rising much faster than inflation.
Image credits: Claude
The AI assessments were more nuanced, with several acknowledging that total employment is at or near record highs and that recent job gains have skewed toward the private sector. But the models also noted that standard mathematical fluctuations make Trump’s absolute claims misleading.
According to a report released on Tuesday by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the U.S. lost 105,000 jobs in October and added 64,000 jobs in November, as the unemployment rate rose to a four-year high of 4.6%.
Trump’s most dramatic rhetoric centered on immigration. He described the country as having been “invaded by an army of 25 million people,” including criminals from prisons and mental institutions, and claimed that for seven months “zero illegal aliens” were allowed into the country.
All four platforms rated these claims as false.
Image credits: Gemini
Claude categorized it as “Grossly false,” while calling the numbers a “massive exaggeration.”
Border encounters under the Biden administration totaled roughly 7 to 10 million, not 25 million, and those figures include repeat encounters.
Trump’s claim that “11,888 murderers” had entered the country was traced to a decades-old U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement list of non-detained individuals with homicide convictions, many of whom entered long before Biden took office.
Another area that all the AI models agreed upon was on the claim that Trump settled eight wars in 10 months, destroyed Iran’s nuclear threat, and ended the war in Gaza, bringing “for the first time in 3,000 years, peace to the Middle East.”
Every platform labeled these assertions false, exaggerated, or unsupported.
Claims that 1,600 new power plants would be opened within a year were flagged as implausible
Image credits: The White House/Flickr
While ceasefires and military actions have occurred, there are no confirmations of Trump ending any wars. In fact, civil societies have warned that despite the ceasefire agreement, the Gaza war has not permanently “ended.”
One claim that stood out for drawing the same criticism across chatbots was Trump’s assertion that drug prices were cut by 400, 500, or even 600%.
All noted the same issue: such reductions are mathematically impossible. A 100% reduction would make a drug free of charge. Anything beyond that has no real-world meaning.
Similarly, claims that 1,600 new power plants would be opened within a year were flagged as implausible, given the timelines required to build generating facilities.
The address was not a first for Trump, who has regularly used hyperbolic language and exaggerated statistics to support his claims—claims that collapse quickly when tested against verifiable facts.